Telecom towers keep their GST credit. Not because they're "plant and machinery" — because they're not immovable property at all
The Supreme Court has twice left a Delhi High Court ruling undisturbed — an SLP dismissed on 8 August 2025, the Revenue's review petition dismissed on 19 August 2026 — holding telecom towers are movable property, so Section 17(5)(d)'s block, which reaches only construction of immovable property, never engages. Towers remain expressly excluded from the Explanation's definition of "plant and machinery" either way — that was never the live question.
Several headlines since the Supreme Court's August 2026 review dismissal read as if the Court ruled telecom towers qualify as "plant and machinery" under GST. That is the one thing the exclusion clause in Section 17(5) was written to rule out — and it is not what either court actually decided. Here is the narrower, correctly-stated question the courts answered, twice now, and why the distinction matters for every capital asset bolted to a floor, wall or rooftop.
What the Supreme Court actually did — and when
Get the procedural posture right first, because a review dismissal carries less weight than a fresh judgment, not more. A bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Prasanna B. Varale dismissed the GST Department's review petitions against Bharti Airtel Ltd, Indus Towers Ltd and Elevar Digitel Infrastructure Pvt Ltd on 19 August 2026, finding "no error apparent on the face of the record" — the narrow standard a review applies, which does not re-open the merits. That review was against the Supreme Court's own earlier order dated 8 August 2025, in which a different bench had already declined to interfere and dismissed the Revenue's special leave petitions at the admission stage. Twice, in other words, the Court has chosen not to disturb the same underlying ruling — which is a real and now twice-reinforced outcome, but still not a reasoned Supreme Court judgment on the point.
The reasoned judgment on record is the Delhi High Court's: Bharti Airtel Limited v. Commissioner, CGST Appeals-1, Delhi (W.P.(C) 13211/2024), with the batched Indus Towers Ltd (W.P.(C) 14710/2024) and Elevar Digitel Infrastructure Pvt Ltd (W.P.(C) 16477/2024) petitions, decided 12 December 2024 by a bench of Justices Yashwant Varma and Girish Kathpalia, reported as 2024 LiveLaw (Del) 1360. That judgment quashed the demand orders and show-cause notices the companies had challenged.
The actual legal question: movable, not "plant and machinery"
Section 17(5)(d) of the CGST Act blocks ITC on goods or services received for construction of an "immovable property (other than plant and machinery) on his own account." The Revenue's case was that a telecom tower, bolted to a rooftop or embedded in a foundation, is immovable property, so the block applies. The telecom companies' answer did not need to reach the "plant and machinery" exception at all: their position, which the Delhi High Court accepted, was that a tower is simply not immovable property in the first place — a steel lattice or pole structure that can be dismantled, moved and re-erected elsewhere remains movable, whatever is true of any concrete base it rests on. Since Section 17(5)(d) only reaches construction of immovable property, a structure that never crosses that threshold is outside the provision regardless of how "plant and machinery" is defined.
The Explanation to Section 17 — which defines "plant and machinery" for Chapters V and VI of the CGST Act (and so for clauses (c) and (d) of Section 17(5)) — expressly excludes "telecommunication towers" from that term, alongside land, buildings, other civil structures, and pipelines laid outside factory premises. The Delhi High Court treated that exclusion as beside the point rather than fatal to the companies' case. Its judgment states it directly, at para 18: "the specific exclusion of telecommunication towers from the scope of the phrase 'plant and machinery' would not lead one to conclude that the statute contemplates or envisages telecommunication towers to be immovable property. Telecommunication towers would in any event have to qualify as immovable property as a pre-condition to fall within the ambit of clause (d) of Section 17(5)." Being excluded from the definition of "plant and machinery" does not, by itself, make a thing immovable — those are two separate questions, and the Revenue's argument conflated them. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's own 20 November 2024 ruling in the earlier Central Excise/service-tax litigation over the same towers — Bharti Airtel Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3374 — which held that mobile towers and prefabricated shelters do not become immovable property merely because they are attached to the earth, affirming the Delhi High Court's 2018 Vodafone Mobile Services view and departing from a contrary 2014 Bombay High Court ruling.
Why "towers are plant and machinery" is the wrong headline
Several reports of this ruling, including some covering the August 2026 review dismissal, describe it as the Supreme Court holding that telecom towers "qualify as plant and machinery." That framing cannot be correct as a matter of the bare statutory text: the Explanation to Section 17 names telecommunication towers as one of the things "plant and machinery" expressly excludes, and nothing in this litigation touched that exclusion. What the courts actually decided is narrower and doesn't need the "plant and machinery" exception to work at all: a tower that is movable property never triggers Section 17(5)(d) in the first place, so the question of whether it falls inside or outside "plant and machinery" simply never arises. Treat any version of this story that leads with "towers are now plant and machinery" as a simplification that gets the mechanism backwards, even though the bottom-line outcome for ITC — the credit survives — is the same either way.
What this does not change
Don't read this as reopening the door Finance Act 2025 closed. Section 17(5)(d)'s block on ITC for construction of a building or other civil structure "on his own account" is retrospectively reinstated from 1 July 2017 (Finance Act 2025, s.124: the substitution of "plant and machinery" for "plant or machinery" is deemed to have applied from that date; the accompanying Explanation 2 took effect 1 October 2025, under Notification 16/2025-Central Tax), and the Safari Retreats "functionality test" no longer applies there. That amendment and this tower litigation address different thresholds entirely: Safari Retreats was about whether an admittedly immovable building could still be treated as a "plant" under clause (d)'s then-wording "plant or machinery" — a route Finance Act 2025 closed by deeming that phrase to always have meant the defined, narrower "plant and machinery", which excludes buildings outright. The telecom-tower cases never reach that question at all: they turn on whether the structure is immovable property in the first place. A building bolted to its foundation plainly is immovable property; a tower assembled from bolted, dismantlable steel sections is the fact pattern the Revenue couldn't establish as such. Don't extend "telecom towers are movable" to any other capital asset without running the same fact-specific test — mode of attachment, whether removal would damage the structure, and whether it was ever meant to be permanent — on that asset's own installation.
What to actually do with this if you run telecom infrastructure
If you're claiming ITC on tower, antenna or shelter capex, the practical task this ruling leaves you with is evidentiary, not legal: document how each asset class is actually installed — bolted lattice sections versus a cast foundation, equipment that can be relocated versus equipment that can't — rather than assuming every site is identical. A field officer can still issue a show-cause notice on a specific site's facts, and "the Supreme Court already decided this" is not, on its own, a complete answer to a fact-specific immovability question. That is exactly the kind of capital-goods ITC line that is painful to track by hand across a large tower or site portfolio — reconciling every capital-goods credit against its own asset classification and documentation, instead of assuming a blanket Section 17(5)(d) block (or a blanket exemption) on anything bolted to land, is what keeps a position defensible site by site.
Don't let one ruling's headline decide every site's credit
Recoup reconciles capital-goods ITC claims against the underlying asset record, so a tower, a shelter and a building don't get the same blanket tag just because one made the news.
Book a demo →Related
Input Tax Credit: eligibility, reversals & the 30-Nov clock
The six conditions, the blocked list, and the two reversal rules that actually bite.
Section 17(5) blocked & ineligible ITC — the full list
Every clause of the blocked-credit list, including the "plant and machinery" carve-out (which this ruling does not turn on).
Section 17(5) (blocked credits)
The provision's text and the "plant and machinery" Explanation, in one place.
GST reconciliation for construction & real estate
Where the immovable-property block genuinely does bite — and stays blocked.